Attention: You are using an outdated browser, device or you do not have the latest version of JavaScript downloaded and so this website may not work as expected. Please download the latest software or switch device to avoid further issues.
| 9 Nov 2026 | |
| Written by Mairi MacNaughton (Macdonald) | |
| Alumnae News |
Dining Room Memories: Queues, Custard and the Quest for Toffee Tart
For generations of St George's girls, lunch was about far more than food. It was a daily ritual of queuing, catching up with friends, and eagerly scanning the menu board to discover what awaited.
The experience began on the stairs, where long queues stretched upwards amid excited chatter. At the top, a peg-board menu revealed the day's offerings. Cheers greeted favourites such as crumble and custard or the legendary toffee tart, while groans accompanied liver and onions, mutton stew, or the much-dreaded tapioca, affectionately known as "frogspawn." Occasionally, mischievous pupils would rearrange the letters on the board to create more entertaining menu options.
Inside, long wooden tables and benches encouraged girls from different years to mix. Teachers or prefects sat at each table, overseeing proceedings while girls quietly plotted how to secure an extra-large helping. Meals began with grace, often in Latin, and once Mrs Lindsay rose to speak, instant silence descended.
Portion sizes became an art form. There were small, medium, large and the coveted "staff large." Popular puddings inspired remarkable confidence when requesting seconds. Mash arrived in perfect ice-cream scoops and the nightmare scenario was dropping a plate, bringing the entire dining hall's attention to the unfortunate culprit.
Opinions on the food were strong and enduring. Friday's "Dog Meat Pie" (a meat loaf believed to contain the week's leftovers) was a favourite, often served with prized tinned tomatoes. Damson crumble with custard or ice cream was much loved, particularly if you could persuade someone to give you the custard skin. Less popular were rice pudding with swollen sultanas, semolina, corned beef and beetroot, greenish liver with "tubey bits," and lumpy mashed potato. Some even recall occasionally finding a cooked slug in the cabbage.
There was little choice. You ate what was served, and many girls remember sitting alone long after lunch trying to finish a dreaded bowl of rice pudding. Boarders had no fridges or snack cupboards to fall back on, leading to inventive attempts to toast bread with an iron and occasional biscuit "liberation" missions.
The undisputed stars were the puddings. Toffee tart achieved near-mythical status, while favourites such as ginger pear crunch, chocolate sponge, flapjacks, Eve's pudding, Swedish apple charlotte, and crumble and custard remain vivid memories decades later. Even jelly with Rice Krispies and cream earned a devoted following. At the other end of the scale sat prunes and custard, semolina, and the unforgettable meal of two tinned peach halves on a lettuce leaf with cottage cheese.
Pupils were invited to sit at the coveted High Table which was presided over by the Headmistress. This was both an honor and an ordeal as one was expected to show excellent manners while making polite conversation.
Across the decades, from the 1950s to the early 2000s, menus changed little and memories remained remarkably consistent. Everyone queued. Everyone hoped for a good pudding. Everyone developed lifelong opinions on beetroot, spam, haggis and tapioca. Most of all, everyone remembers being permanently hungry.
The dining room was more than a place to eat. It was where friendships formed, stories were created, small acts of rebellion flourished and, whatever the main course brought, there was always hope that pudding would save the day.